On Slush Piles and Finding Agents
This photo of the decidedly undaunting St. Martin’s slush pile (the bottom shelf), which Frances Dinklespiel posted about on her wonderful blog, Ghost Word, got me thinking. Of all the author guest posts on 1st Books, only one has used the term “slush.” But I certainly came up from the slush pile, and I expect many of the authors who have guest posted for me have as well.
This St. Martin’s photo isn’t the room packed with manuscripts many of us imagine – or that I used to imagine, anyway. Perhaps that’s in part because, as Frances writes, someone has just been through it. I suspect it’s also in part because most writers approach the publishing world through agents these days.
So I thought I’d throw in my two cents about how to get an agent:
1. Write the best book you can;
2. Write the most intriguing one page query letter you can;
3. Make a list of agents you think might be interested; and
4. Send, and send, and send!
For making that agent list, I recommend making a list of authors you admire (preferably ones who write books something like yours), and then doing internet searches with each author name and the word “agent.” This will usually turn up each author’s agent. If you can’t find the agent’s website, a quick check at aaronline.org will generally get you their contact information.
When you start getting rejections – and we all do – take a look at your query letter and your manuscript again, and try to make them better, and send again.
Losing faith? Some of the posts here that tell inspiring stories of authors getting picked up by agents after many, many rejections include Medical School Takes a Long Time, Too, by Kirsten Menger Anderson (who spent over a year finding an agent for a novel that is now a finalist for the Northern California Book Award); The 46th Time is the Charm; and my personal favorite – and the one that uses the S-word: bestselling author Brenda Rickman Vantrease’s incredibly inspiring A 136-Rejection Overnight Success.
Really, honestly and truly, you do not need to have a connection to land an agent. It’s nice to have writer-pals for a lot of reasons, including for sharing critique and support like I do with my own writing gang, and like the friends in The Wednesday Sisters do when they form their writing group.
But every hardworking agent out there dreams of discovering the world’s next great writer. And if you were an agent, wouldn’t you think discovering a writer yourself through your slush pile would be more satisfying than having someone else find them and recommend them to you? – Meg
Posted in Meg's Posts



April 13th, 2009 at 3:23 am
As an agent, I don’t think I would much care where I found a good writer, as long as I found them.
As a writer, I know I don’t much care how I attract an agent’s attention. It doesn’t matter what kind of referral I’ve got, if I don’t have a manuscript to keep that attention, it won’t matter.
As it happens, an agent did pick me out of the query slush and I feel pretty good about that. But if a referral had opened the door, I’d still feel pretty good about it, because it still would have been my writing that kept me on the right side of the door when it closed.
All of this is nitpicking, of course, and I’m sorry. Your main point, that you can find and win an agent without any contacts in the industry, is entirely valid.
April 22nd, 2009 at 12:27 am
Meg, this is encouraging! Also Frances’ photo of the slush pile.
May 4th, 2009 at 5:56 pm
Hi Meg,
Just heard about your website from Heylady…. and I totally agree with your advice. I got my agent the old-fashioned way — through the slush pile. Agents really do read queries, and now that many of them ask for queries to be emailed, the turn-around time can be very quick.
When my novel was complete, I went to a bookstore and spent a day searching the acknowledgments sections of books I loved. I figured if an author thanked her agent, it was a good sign. You can always google, of course, but I tend to forget the names of all the authors I love.
Can’t wait to read your book — just read the rave on HeyLady’s website!
Best,
Sarah